The Adolf Beck Scandal: A Man Convicted Twice by Mistaken Identity
This is the story of Adolf Beck, a Norwegian man convicted twice in Victorian London because dozens of witnesses swore he was a swindler. His case exposed how confident human memory can be catastrophically wrong and forced Britain to create its first Court of Criminal Appeal.
Listen in the Fylom app.
Adolf Beck served five years of hard labor after being mistaken for a con artist named John Smith.
Fifteen different women incorrectly identified Beck as a thief during his second arrest in nineteen hundred and four.
King Edward the Seventh granted Beck a free pardon after the real offender was caught weeks later.
The British government increased Beck's compensation to five thousand pounds following intense public pressure.
Thirty-one reform bills failed in Parliament before the Beck scandal finally forced legal changes.
The Criminal Appeal Act of nineteen hundred and seven established the first formal mechanism to challenge jury decisions.
- 01Intro1 min
- 02The First Fall of Adolf Beck2 min
- 03The Impossible Coincidence2 min
- 04The Truth Emerges2 min
- 05A Century of Resistance2 min
- 06The Birth of the Court1 min
- 07Outro1 min
- Adolf Beck case
- Adolf Beck (1896 conviction)
- The strange case of Adolf Beck: Press influence and criminal ...
- The Mistaken Mr. Beck - Postcard History
- 19th century court case with all the hallmarks in today's ...
- Convicting the Innocent - Adolf Beck - Victims of the State
- The strange case of Adolf Beck
- Committee of Inquiry into the Case of Mr. Adolf Beck :: report from the committee : together with minutes of evidence, appendix, and facsimiles of various documents.
- Wrongful Conviction—Compensation for Adolf Beck. (Hansard, 3 August 1904)
- Case Of Adolf Beck—Mistaken Identity - Hansard - UK Parliament
- A MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE.. » 25 Oct 1924 »
- Court of Criminal Appeal (England and Wales) - Wikipedia
- Remedying miscarriages of justice: the history of the Court of ...
- Criminal courts: appeal cases
- England (Chapter 5) - Justice for Some
- Overview of the judiciary
- CCR0048 - Evidence on Criminal Cases Review Commission
- COA review of legal year 2006-7 Criminal Division
Fylom generates episodes like this on any topic you're curious about.
Fylom episodes are researched, written, and voiced by AI. Automated checks help catch inaccuracies, but episodes aren't reviewed by a human and AI can still get things wrong. Treat them as a starting point, not a source of record — more in our accuracy disclaimer.